LIBRARY
Blog Copy
by Coach Jeff Sankoff M.D. (a.k.a. the Tri-Doc)
With the completion of the Ironman women’s World Championship in Kona this past weekend more than two thousand weary competitors will begin the process of returning home. As they sit on aircraft filled with other competitors, spectators and vacationers, some will be exposed to pathogens that will make them ill and this will cause many to wonder, ‘Did racing make me sick?’
As a coach whose full-time job is an emergency physician, this is one of the more common questions that I get asked, especially during the fall and winter months when respiratory viruses circulate much more within the population.
This question took on particular significance in the past few years since the emergence of the novel coronavirus Covid-19. Athletes have become much more attuned to anything that might make them more prone to catching that particularly unpleasant pathogen.
So, what then is the answer about how exercise affects our immune system and whether training and racing can make us sick?
How does exercise affect the immune system?
The immune system is very complex and made up of several different cell types and organs. In addition, numerous hormones modulate the function of the system and can impact the susceptibility to infection.
At its root the core function of the immune system is to recognize self from non-self. In other words, the immune system is set up to recognize invaders and repel them using a wide variety of effective and in many cases violent, (albeit on an exceptionally microscopic scale) measures.
A recent review article published in Sport Sciences for Health provided a review of much of the literature on this subject and gave an overview of the current understanding of how exercise and immune function relate to one another.[i]
Early research in this area showed that those who exercise regularly tend to have a lower rate of respiratory infections during cold seasons. Specifically, exercise in this context is described as daily activity of moderate intensity (60-80%of VO2 max) leading to an associated decrease in upper respiratory tract infections of 20-30% over the cold and flu season.i,[ii]
The mechanism by which exercise is believed to improve resistance to infection is by increasing the amount of a specific immunoglobulin in the saliva and respiratory tract.
Immunoglobulin A, or IgA, is commonly found in the respiratory and gastrointestinal tracts where it binds non-specifically to invading viruses and other infectious organisms. IgA provides only a relatively modest first line of defense but when levels of this immunoglobulin are high, there can be heightened levels of protection.
Several studies have shown that both men and women who regularly exercise at moderate intensity have significantly higher levels of salivary IgA than do matched sedentary controls.
However, anecdotally many athletes will relate that they associate races with episodes of illness. As if to confirm this, a study conducted in 1982 on 140 marathon runners in Cape Town, 33% of runners reported URTI symptoms in the 2 weeks after the event, compared with 15% for the same age group who were at home at the same time. Other studies have demonstrated similar findings.
It turns out that in single high intensity, longer duration efforts, immune function rather than being augmented is depressed. In part this has to do with a decrease in IgA levels but there appear to be other mechanisms implicated as well. Specialized white blood cells integral to the host response in warding off infection (neurophils and natural killer cells) are both decreased in number and have stilted function after such events. Recovery to normal levels and function takes about 24-72 hours. This period of one to three days during which immune function is depressed has come to be referred to as the ‘open window’ to infection.
At this point it is important to add that the level of immune function is not the only factor in the equation that determines whether an athlete will become ill. This is because to develop a respiratory illness an individual needs not only to be susceptible but also to be exposed.
Consider two athletes. One is training at low to moderate intensity in their usual fashion and gaining a robust immune system as one of the many benefits from their dedication to their routine. However, their roommate has come down with a nasty cold. And in sharing the same living space, the athlete is exposed repeatedly to viral particles over several days and eventually catches the virus and becomes sick.
The second athlete undertakes a specific challenge, say the Ironman World Championship. After thirteen grueling hours in the lava fields and the Energy Lab they are spent but content at their accomplishment. For the next three days this athlete is relatively immunosuppressed. However, this athlete remains in Kona on holiday, with only her family. She does not immediately fly home and therefor is unexposed to anyone who might be contagious and therefor does not become ill.
You can see from this example that the effect on immune function is only one small part of the picture and to make decisions about how to train or race, an athlete needs to consider a more global assessment of risk.
How then can athletes who undertake prolonged high intensity efforts protect themselves from contracting a contagious disease during the open window of depressed immune function?
Despite what you have heard and what many will continue to say, there are simply no supplements or dietary measures that enhance immune function. No vitamins, minerals or specific foods have ever been shown to effectively prevent infections of any kind (with the exception of clostridium difficile, an entirely different subject). Maintaining a balanced, healthy diet is a good idea under any condition so doing so after these kinds of efforts is no different just don’t expect that adding supplements or focusing on blueberries will make any difference.
As we have seen with Covid, and it is true for all contagious illnesses, the only way to effectively prevent infection is simply to not allow for exposure and when that cannot be done, to then take all the precautions necessary to minimize infection. Social distancing, wearing a mask and meticulous handwashing are all best practices and will keep even the most immunosuppressed individuals safer than not.
The take-home message here is don’t let the fear of becoming sick get in the way of doing big efforts or special challenges just take precautions to keep yourself healthy afterwards.
Train hard, train healthy.
[i] Sabzevari Rad R. The impact of different training intensities on athletes’ immune system function and the management of upper respiratory traction infections: a narrative review. Sport Sci Health. 2023;1:3. doi:10.1007/s11332-023-01110-7
[ii] Simpson RJ, Kunz H, Agha N, Graff R. Exercise and the Regulation of Immune Functions. doi:10.1016/bs.pmbts.2015.08.001
by Coach Jeff Sankoff, M.D.
Running Shoes and The Biomechanical Tradeoffs They Bring to Runners: Risks and Benefits?
Human beings have been walking upright for millions of years and beginning approximately two million years ago even began running long distances. Given that the first evidence of simple footwear dates to only around 40,000 years ago that means that for most of our species’ time on this planet we have run barefoot.
In some parts of the world, barefoot running is still the preferred means of locomotion and it is clear that our feet are very well adapted for this purpose. However, in our built world with its unforgiving concrete surfaces we no longer spend as much time on our feet as our ancestors did and those of us who do run tend to do so for very different reasons and for very different amount of times than they did as well. Because of all this, we have adopted the use of specialized running shoes to help us navigate an environment that is much more hostile to our feet than the ancient plains were. Shoes also help us avoid injury since our feet, though evolutionarily unchanged, are less prepared to handle the stress of running in the way that we do now.
Since the 1970’s when manufacturers began to develop shoes with both performance and injury prevention in mind, running shoes have taken a diverse array of designs. From high cushioned heels with embedded carbon plates and highly elastic foams in the sole to minimalist shoes with almost no cushioning and extremely supple footbeds with every variation imaginable in between.
The variety in shoe design is matched by the innumerable opinions about whether any of them actually benefit injury prevention or to a lesser degree performance. What is not in dispute, is the idea that each of the design choices that shoe manufacturers make bring with it benefits at the expense of certain tradeoffs related to alterations in the biomechanics of the feet, ankles and knees each of which carry with them potential pitfalls.
A recent article in the journal Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews from Harvard University evolutionary biologists Ali Yawar and Daniel Lieberman examines these tradeoffs in detail.[i] This is not done in an effort to suggest that somehow today’s cushioned shoes are bad. Rather, they merely point out that humans evolved to be able to run efficiently and that engineered shoes offer benefits that often bring with them unintended consequences.
Today’s high tech running shoes feature more than twenty different independent design features but six of them are believed to be the most important in terms of their biomechanical effects and the paper goes into detail explaining each of them.
- Shoe mass
When running, the metabolic cost attributable to swinging the leg forward from the take-off position to the landing position for the next step is significant. Estimates are that up to 20% of the metabolic cost of running is for this activity alone. The reason for this has to do with the size of the feet that average about 9% of the total mass of the leg.
Foot mass has a significant impact on running economy with every 100g added being shown to increase the metabolic cost by 1%. With larger, more cushioned shoes there is an appreciable increase in mass to the foot and a resultant increase in the metabolic needs for running. However, and here is where the biomechanical tradeoffs come in, the authors argue that because the cushioning in the sole may act to help a runner save energy in other ways and provide kinetic tradeoffs that will improve speed there is a net benefit to increasing the mass of the shoe.
- Compressive stiffness of the sole
As sole thickness increases so too does the compressive stiffness. This physical property has a direct effect on how ground forces are absorbed by the foot and the leg when running.
Early on when running became very popular and running injuries began to increase in a commensurate fashion, those injuries were theorized to be a direct result of the repetitive force of impact of the foot against the ground. By providing cushioning in the form of a thick and minimally compressive sole manufacturers hypothesized, injuries could be reduced because the collision force would be absorbed by the shoe itself instead of the structures of the foot and leg.
There is some evidence to show that this does happen. Thicker soled, softer shoes do indeed slow the rate of impact with the ground allowing for the force to be dissipated more gradually than is the case when running barefoot. However, just like with shoe mass, there is an important tradeoff here as well that must be considered and helps explain why cushioning alone does not simply obviate all impact related running injuries.
The key tradeoff here is that with a thicker soled, softer shoe, the rate of impact with the ground is slowed but the duration of the impact lasts longer and so while the maximal force is lower than without cushioning the total impact force is greater because it lasts for longer. This is referred to as the impact impulse.
This tradeoff is variable across runners with different gaits. Those who run with a heel strike are affected most while those who run with a forefoot landing see a decrease in impact impulse when wearing cushioned shoes.
- Sole bending stiffness
The stiffer the sole of the shoe, the more resistant it becomes to bending. With decreased bending, the push off point for the foot moves forward and there is more strain placed on the Achilles tendon to lever this longer platform around the ankle joint in order to propel the body forward (see figure 1). The result of this shift in push off point is to create a bigger gear ratio for the ankle joint and allow for increased speed of propulsion.
However, there is a tradeoff for the creation of this larger gear. In a study that evaluated runners using shoes with differing sole stiffness, researchers found that the metabolic cost associated

with running in stiffer shoes was increased though there was a relationship to running speed. Running at higher speeds reduced metabolic costs while running at lower speeds increased those costs. This has important relevance for the use of shoes with carbon fiber plates embedded in the soles. Those plates add significant stiffness to the sole of the shoe and this research would suggest that slower runners may be paying a penalty for using them in the form of a higher metabolic cost than if they used a softer soled shoe.
- Arch support
The arches of our feet evolved over millennia to serve an important purpose related to running. The medial longitudinal arch (MLA) and the transverse tarsal arch (TTA) together stiffen the foot making it resistant to deforming upon landing and the former functions as a spring, storing energy on landing and then releasing it as we take off. Arch supports consist of stiff materials in the sole of the shoe underneath the two arches minimizing or preventing them from deforming.
Arch supports result in yet another important tradeoff; by reducing the deformation of the MLA, the plantar fascia and small intrinsic muscles of the foot are protected from strain but this comes at the cost of potentially developing weakness in those structures and increasing risk of injury (arch supports can be used in situations when the plantar fascia has already been injured as this may confer protection from further injury to some degree). Furthermore, arch support compromises the natural spring function of the MLA reducing running economy. In some studies the cost has been measured to be as much as 6%.
- Larger heel-to-toe offset (HTO).
A thicker heeled shoe results in a larger drop to the forefoot. This is called the heel-to-toe offset (HTO). As described earlier, a thicker heel results in a reduced rate of loading to the foot and ankle but with a higher overall impact impulse. However, HTO has other consequences to biomechanics because of the way it causes the foot to be in a plantar flexed position on standing and on striking the ground (see figure 2). This reduces how much force can be generated by the ankle, previously noted as an important component of generating running velocity, and often results in longer stride lengths and changes in the biomechanical interactions of the joints of the lower leg because of the change in position of the foot and ankle upon landing.

Shoes with higher HTO also have wider flare of the sole out from the heel ostensibly to provide more stability for the runner. Unfortunately, these flared heels actually increase the likelihood of eversion of the ankle (rolling the ankle) because of the fact that the flared sole allows for a larger lever that can exert a rotational force on the ankle joint with each step (see figure 3).

Figure 3: Shoes with a higher HTO have a more flared heel and can contribute to more ankle instability. Because there is more mass and distance from the ankle joint to the outer aspect of the shoe sole, there is a larger ‘lever handle’ represented by Fx+rx putting a rotational force on the ankle joint and increasing the risk of eversion (rolling the ankle). Reproduced from Yawar A, Lieberman DE. Biomechanical Tradeoffs in Foot Function From Variations in Shoe Design. Exerc Sport Sci Rev. 2023;51(4):128-139. With permission of the author.
- Increased sole thickness and decreased proprioception.
The final characteristic of shoe development that carries with it important tradeoffs is the thickness of the sole of the shoe and how that alters our ability to sense the terrain upon which we are walking or running. Our feet are imbued with an incredibly rich network of sensory receptors to allow us to receive feedback about the ground we are walking upon and also in order to be able to remain upright. With thicker and softer soles, this sensory feedback is lost and there may be an increased risk of falling. One author showed that regardless of age, softer soled shoes were associated with more difficulty keeping balance.
The rapid and diverse development of running shoes over the past several decades has resulted in several important biomechanical tradeoffs to provide today’s runners with better protection, injury prevention and comfort. None of these tradeoffs should be viewed as a means of making an argument that running barefoot is preferred to running with highly engineered shoes. Instead, we should view these as they are intended, as insights to how shoes and runners interact and to help us understand how to better select for features that can improve an individual’s ability to run comfortably and more likely remain injury free.
Of all the shoe design features listed and examined by Yawar and Lieberman, sole thickness is the one that is associated with the most important tradeoffs because it relates so intimately to several other features such as shoe mass, sole stiffness, heel height and arch support. As more and more triathletes adopt so-called super shoes, those with special foams and carbon fiber plates embedded in the soles, the potential costs of these shoes must be measured against the advertised benefits. Triathletes need to be honest about what type of runner they are and what they want from their shoes, comfort, injury prevention or performance.
Keeping in mind the very real metabolic costs of some of these features, runners may be better suited to choose a shoe that matches their running style and performance rather than looking for a shoe that they believe will transform them into something they are not.
Train hard, train healthy.
[i] Yawar A, Lieberman DE. Biomechanical Tradeoffs in Foot Function From Variations in Shoe Design. Exerc Sport Sci Rev. 2023;51(4):128-139. doi:10.1249/JES.0000000000000322
December 11, 2023
Are you ready for 70.3 Washington? Join our camp on August 30, 2026!
LifeSport race preparation clinics are an incredible way to gain course-specific knowledge in advance of race day. Join Columbia Gorge-based LifeSport Coach and two time 70.3 Age Group World Champion, Juliet Hochman, for a full-day camp to make 70.3 Tri-Cities your best race yet! Juliet won her age group here in 2024 and 2025 and was top 3 overall this past year. Let her offer you a sneak peek into its downriver swim, rolling bike course through beautiful vineyards and riverside run. Join Juliet for a race-specific training day to prep you for a 70.3 personal best. Clinic includes:
- Course preview for 70.3 Tri-Cities in Richland, Washington – we will preview the swim course and ride parts of the bike and run courses!
- Managing your race day for optimal performance
- 70.3 bike and run pacing using heart rate and/or power
- Nutrition and hydration guidelines
- Maximizing your open water performance with a rolling start and a river swim
- Mental preparation
- Race week logistics
All levels welcome. Bring snacks and lunch. Camp starts at 7:00 a.m. with a swim in the river. This full day clinic runs until 2:30 or 3:00pm and the cost is $95.
Want to make a triathlon weekend out of it? Come race the Plutonium Man Triathlon the day before on August 29 and get double the experience, particularly with that downriver swim, then join us for dinner on Saturday night before the clinic. Sprint and Olympic distance races with the course at the north end of the 70.3 run course. Details coming soon!
Check out this webinar, created in partnership with IRONMAN, for a full preview of the race!
Questions? Email Juliet at juliet@lifesportcoaching.com for more information.
To hold your spot for the triathlon race clinic, sign up here!